Which invader could steal past the Tower of London?
Heritage Key are holding a competition, asking for blog posts about “Which invaders have had the biggest impact on London?” I can’t enter for various reasons, but it’s an interesting question. In the spirit of creatively coming up with the wrong answer, I’m going to go for:
Yersinia pestis
Y. pestis is without doubt the invader who has had the biggest impact, for certain definitions of invader and impact. I think it’s an invader, because it’s thought to have come from the Gobi desert originally. It’s certainly had impact, because no other invader has come close to killing half of London’s population. If you’re wondering which invader killed so many people, it’s thought that Y. pestis in one form or another was the bacterium that caused the Black Death.
It arrived in the UK in 1348. One record is the Grey Friars Chronicle, which has the best description:
In this year 1348 in Melcombe, in the county of Dorset, a little before the feast of St. John the Baptist, two ships, one of them from Bristol came alongside. One of the sailors had brought with him from Gascony the seeds of the terrible pestilence and through him the men of that town of Melcombe were the first in England to be infected.
In reality it probably came in on several ships from across the channel. News of the plague spread much faster than the plague itself, so Gloucester was able to prepare by shutting the gates of the city. As a plan this would have worked if the rats had been trained to enter the city by the commercial routes. For somewhere like London this was not a remotely plausible strategy, and so the population would have been awaiting what seemed like the judgement of a wrathful god. It arrived in London by autumn of the same year, almost certainly aboard a ship rather than from an overland route.
If you were a killer bug with a penchant for pestilence then 1300s London would have been paradise. Hitching a ride in the gut of a flea, you could have transferred to a human or one of the many millions of rats which thrived in the squalor of the city. The hygiene practices of the time, and I use the word hygiene wholly incorrectly, meant that there was a plentiful supply of fresh rats to incubate a travelling plague. It gave the disease a tremendous longevity, in sad contrast to its many victims. If you measure impact purely in terms of people dead, then it’s hard to find anything with greater impact than Y. pestis, which hung around till 1665. Yet it’s not just death that made Y. pestis London’s greatest invader.
Across Britain a third of the population died. The landscape is littered with what archaeologists call DMVs, Deserted Medieval Villages. You can still see them around today with the occasional church in the middle of nowhere, with no obvious congregation. You can’t remove that many people without something breaking, and in the Middle Ages, this was Feudalism. Before the plague serfs had been tied to their master’s estates. The massive culling of the population by the Black Death increased the value of labourers, and set in motion a series of revolts and uprisings which would eventually end Feudalism.
Another effect was the abandonment of land. This helped place more wealth in hands of the church. This wealth helped fuel the conflicts between church and state in later times. More controversially, it’s also been proposed that agricultural use of land could have affected the climate. Bill Ruddiman has argued that the plague led to reforestation of the land, reducing the carbon concentration of the atmosphere, ultimately leading to cooling in the Little Ice Age. This is not a mainstream idea, but it is taken seriously by many climate researchers and does appear in climate change journals, rather than social sciences journals.
Regardless of the climactic consequences, it’s interesting to ask if the Renaissance would have happened without the Black Death. Some of the social changes were happening before the arrival of the plague, but at the very least Y. pestis amplified them. The removal of so many people from the population wasn’t just a quantative change, it was a qualitative change, because it meant rethinking how people were valued in an economy. The Black Death fuelled social changes in the Late Middle Ages which would eventually blossom as the Renaissance. Still, this is one historical character who might not stay in the past. Y. pestis may yet have a role to play in the future.
If you’re interested in reading more about the arrival of the Black Death as an invasion, there’s a very readable chapter in Benedictow’s book The Black Death, 1346-1353: the complete history available in Google Books.
